Sydney and Melbourne house prices could fall by as much as 30 per cent, while Hobart house prices could rise by 5 per cent, according to SQM Research Louis Christopher’s Boom and Bust Report.
Hobart house prices could rise by nine per cent next year, bucking the national trend if interest rates are cut in response to rapidly falling house prices in Sydney and Melbourne.
That’s according to leading property analyst SQM Research’s annual Boom and Bust Report, who have warned falling house prices and changes to negative gearing could spark a recession.
The report forecasts big price falls for Australia’s housing market next year, led by Sydney and Melbourne. Peak to trough price falls of 12 per cent to 17 per cent have been predicted for the country’s two biggest housing markets.
Source: SQM Research
But if negative gearing is repealed (a firmly stated Labor party objective) that number may rise to 30 per cent by 2020.
SQM Research’s Louis Christopher says the range is entirely dependent on:
- When, if and how the RBA responds to the downturn;
- How the economy responds to the downturn;
- Will the banks be required to lift rates out of cycle;
- Will negative gearing and capital gains tax concessions be repealed as per the Labor Party’s policy.
“If the RBA does not respond and/or the bank lift interest rates again in 2019, it is possible the peak to trough falls in Sydney and Melbourne could be even more than this negative range. But we do take the view that the downturn in Sydney and Melbourne will be a significant negative for the overall economy, and so the central bank will eventually respond at some point and cut interest rates,” Mr Christopher said.
“The looming changes of Negative Gearing and Capital Gains Tax are increasingly weighing on investor sentiment. Quite frankly implementing these changes during a housing downtown is very risky and may trip the economy into a recession,” Mr Christopher added.
Head of Research at Propertyology, Simon Pressley agrees with Mr Christopher’s concerns about the risk of recession.
“Australia already had responsible lending policies. Clearly, we needed better policing of those existing policies. Instead, what we’ve seen from APRA is radical and unreasonable reform that, unless stopped, poses a real risk of a road to recession,” Mr Pressley told WILLIAMS MEDIA.
“If someone doesn’t intercept quickly, that snowball of financial woe that has started rolling down the hill will have built up a significant head of steam that may ultimately cause considerable economic destruction,” Mr Pressley said.
President of the Real Estate Institute of Australia (REIA) Malcolm Gunning says the government needs to be mindful of the impacts on the economy.
“Government and regulators should be very mindful of the impact that a lack of confidence in the housing market can have on the economy. The continued decline in housing finance reflect the slowing market, APRA restrictions which with hindsight were probably excessive, the fallout from the Royal Commission into Banking and concerns about changes to property taxation and its impact should there be a change in Government,” Mr Gunning told WILLIAMS MEDIA.
Housing Industry Association (HIA) Acting Principal Economist, Geordan Murray says because the effects of APRA’s measures are untested in a market downturn, it’s not overly surprising that house prices are declining.
“The role that APRA’s interventions in the mortgage market are having is a unique aspect of this cycle. The tighter lending environment is an additional contributing factor to the softer housing finance figures. APRA’s measures are untested in a market downturn and the effect needs to monitored closely. The housing price cycle still has time to run and throughout the phase where prices are easing we should expect to see fewer property transactions and soft housing finance numbers,” Mr Murray told WILLIAMS MEDIA.
Real Estate Institute of New South Wales (REINSW) CEO, Tim McKibbin says stamp duty is having a huge effect on the NSW property market.
“People no longer want to transact property because of taxation. Families would expand and move into a house after owning a unit, but now they are electing to stay where they are and renovate rather than finding a new property,” Mr McKibbin told WILLIAMS MEDIA.
Mr McKibbin said if the Government is serious about Stamp Duty reform it must adjust the brackets to reflect today’s median house price, and then index it from there.
Real Estate Institute of Victoria President, Robyn Waters says median prices are actually rising in Melbourne.
“We’ve all heard the ‘doom and gloom’ commentary about a downturn in Melbourne’s property market but the median house price has actually increased five per cent in the past 12 months. The property boom of 2017 could not be sustained and a levelling or correction of the market is a good thing in the context of housing affordability already being a pressing issue in Melbourne,” Ms Waters told WILLIAMS MEDIA.